Section 23 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms is creating a quiet revolution in the Toronto school system.
Thirty years on, it seems Torontonians are finally twigging to the
implications of Section 23, the bit that guarantees parents the right,
under certain conditions, to educate their children in French.
According to the Charter, if your first language is French, or if you
were educated in French, your children have the right to French
education. This applies to people born in Canada, as well as immigrants
from the approximately 50 countries where French is an official
language. And according to an executive at the French Catholic system in
Toronto, admission in his system is extended further through a
"grandfather" clause, which allows any child with a French-speaking or
French-educated grandparent to register, as well.
In a country with
about seven million native French speakers, whose population growth is
increasingly dependent on immigration, and in a city like Toronto that
acts as a magnet for both domestic and international migration, that
accounts for a lot of kids.
The French classes mandated in the English school system are mostly
lamentable. French immersion has become enormously competitive, with far
fewer spots than kids. But a spot in a French immersion program is not
guaranteed by the Charter. Wholesale French education is.
So when a
school in Toronto's public or Catholic French school boards gets
crowded, it doesn't turn students way or get ludicrously selective, it
expands. The Catholic school board, the
Conseil scolaire de district catholique Centre-Sud (CSDCCS) has grown by more than 10 per cent over the last four years. The public system, the
Conseil Scolaire Viamonde,
by 23 per cent. Because land zoned for schools is at a premium in the
GTA, expansion has in the past meant crowded classrooms and portables.
But ever since 2006, when the Ministry of Education has its
Pupil Accommodation Review, which
forced the English system to consolidate its students, shutter sparsely
populated schools and offer those schools up to other boards before
they could put them on the open market, the French systems have been
positively blossoming.
"We're building a new elementary school is Scarborough," says Rejean
Sirois, the director of education for the Catholic system, "and we're
also building a new school northwest of the 401 to replace an existing
school." The growth is impressive. They're also expanding two elementary
schools that are over-crowded, have received funding to buy a school in
Etobicoke (formerly known as Richview), have already bought the former
Essex public school near Christie Pits and have a new high school at the
corner of Eglinton and Markham Road. The public system has five new
schools in the works, including the school formerly known as West
Toronto Collegiate, a three-storey, 1,000-student school they're
renovating jointly with the Catholic board. On Lansdowne between College
and Bloor, the as yet un-named school is in the heart of Dufferin
Grove, and will open up some much needed spots in the downtown core.
"Every time we open a school, like the
École Mosaique
three years ago, people just show up," says Gyslaine Hunter-Perrault,
the education director at Viamonde. She says it's a classic
built-it-and-they-come model. There aren't huge waiting lists for
existing schools. Even parents who qualify to have their kids educated
in French tend to value proximity over all else, and will enroll their
kids in the English system rather than subject them to a 45-minute
commute. "It's a bit like a chicken and egg thing," she says. "People
aren't waiting on the sidewalk, but when we open one, people come from
all over to register." When the public system, which covers everything
from Windsor to Penetanguishene, started up in 1998, there were 21
schools. Now there are 41, all of them full.
Bilingualism has been in the background of Canadian history and culture
at least as far back as Baldwin and Lafontaine, but it's mostly been a
failure. In most of Canada, French education produces little more than
an ability to pronounce "Québec" slightly better than an American. In
Québec itself, English is in as sorry a state as French is elsewhere.
With the exception of New Brunswick, the nation's only officially
bilingual province, bilingualism is still more ideal than reality. But
the promise of a flourishing Toronto French system is extraordinary.
"All our students when they graduate are fully bilingual," Sirois says.
Not only do the schools employ only native French speakers, everything
from assemblies to sports are conducted in French. Because English
remains the primary language outside of school, both French boards are
able to teach English, beginning in grade four, at a level that far
surpasses the English systems' ability to teach French. By high school,
the English courses the French students take are the same ones their
English counterparts are taking, complete with Shakespeare and Robertson
Davies.
The Charter provision has ensured that the growth of such systems is
potentially geometric, with every child admitted to the system
automatically qualifying their future children for eventual admission.
It's the same in the rest of Anglo Canada as well, of course, but for
the most part, the parental enthusiasm has not been there, and those
with Section 23 rights have largely abdicated them in favour of English
assimilation. But Toronto seems to have started to buck the trend.
Though both French systems extend beyond its borders, the GTA accounts
for the fastest growth. And with Haitians, West Africans, Egyptians and
Lebanese, not to mention French Canadians, all taking advantage of their
rights to French education in the middle of an Anglophone city, it may
only take a couple of generations for Toronto to become a true
encapsulation of the Canadian ideal.
Bert Archer is the development editor of Yonge Street.
Originally published on Yonge Street on Feb. 22, 2012.