Ontario's health minister bowed to months of opposition pressure and tendered
his resignation Tuesday on the eve of a report into how the province spent $1
billion over 10 years to create electronic health records and handed out
millions in untendered contracts, The Canadian Press has learned.
Sources told the news agency David
Caplan notified Premier Dalton McGuinty that he would step down in advance of
the auditor general's special report into eHealth Ontario.
Liberal government sources refused to
confirm Caplan's resignation. A spokesman for McGuinty said only that the
premier would respond to the auditor's report at a news conference Wednesday
that was originally scheduled to be Caplan's event.
Auditor General Jim McCarter will
release a 50-page special report, which was commissioned last June as the
Liberal government tried to defend itself against growing reports about
sole-sourced contracts and expense claims by high paid consultants at eHealth.
Those questionable expenses included
allowing consultants who were paid up to $2,700 a day to bill taxpayers extra
for minor purchases like tea and snacks.
So far, the media have reported on
millions in untendered eHealth contracts that were given to consultants, some of
whom had close ties to top executives at the provincial agency, and were even
paid for consulting each other, driving up their fees.
Even now, months after the scandal
first broke and forced the government to replace both eHealth CEO Sarah Kramer
and chair Alan Hudson, there are still almost 300 consultants under contract at
the agency - down from 385 in April.
The departures of Kramer and Hudson
did little to quiet opposition demands that Caplan resign. In 2007, the
political veteran weathered the scandal over insider wins at the Ontario Lottery
and Gaming Corp., which also saw the opposition calling for his ouster.
Details of some controversial eHealth
contracts have been spilling out since last May, including one $30-million,
sole-sourced deal for IBM that was approved by a powerful committee of the
Liberal cabinet and could prove very troubling for the government.
That's because most of the other
contracts were given out by Kramer, who was paid $317,000 at the height of the
scandal to leave the job she had held for less than a year, or by other eHealth
executives and were not specifically approved by cabinet ministers.
"What we've heard from this
government up until now is it's an arms-length agency, they've been making their
own decisions, but clearly it's happening at the highest levels of government as
well," said Progressive Conservative critic Christine Elliott.
"The example has been set that it's
OK to do that, and so we've seen these agencies follow suit."
The New Democrats agreed the IBM
contract could be key to the auditor general's report Wednesday.
"It goes to the point that the
corruption and the rot goes right up to the top," said NDP Leader Andrea
Horwath.
"The propensity to shove these
contracts out the door without a proper tendering process went straight to the
top, to management board of cabinet."
The opposition parties had been
demanding Caplan's resignation for months, saying the government was quick to
replace bureaucrats like Kramer and Hudson but wouldn't hold a cabinet minister
responsible.
"They've thrown as many people as
they can under the bus, and now the circle is tightening and sooner or later
it's going to be one of their own that will have to step down," Elliott said
Tuesday before word of Caplan's resignation broke.
The NDP also said Caplan had to
resign if the government wanted to move beyond the eHealth scandal, and rejected
the Liberals' defence that the problems covered in the auditor general's report
will date back a decade, four years before they came to power.
"All of these scandals happened under
their watch, so for the government to try to deflect blame to historic practices
is unacceptable and it's just that, a deflection of the highest order," said
Horwath.
Governments of all stripes in the
past allowed untendered contracts, but the Liberals changed the rules for all
ministries and arms-length agencies, boards and commissions to prohibit the
practice, Deputy Premier George Smitherman told the legislature Tuesday.
"We've set a new standard and
eliminated the prospect for sole sourcing," said Smitherman.
"They did it. We've done it. It's
been the pattern, but it's been changed and we've raised the bar."
EHealth was set up last fall after
its predecessor, Smart Systems for Health, spent about $650 million and produced
so little it was quietly shut down on a Friday and replaced with eHealth the
next Monday.