The national debate over gun control that many Canadians thought had been
resolved a decade ago has roared back to life after the House of Commons voted
in principle Wednesday to end the long-gun registry.
The minority Conservative government
got help from 12 New Democrats, eight Liberals and one Independent to pass a
private member's bill that would kill the registry, expunge records on more than
seven million firearms, and plow under a $1-billion taxpayer investment
The 164-137 vote in favour of Bill
C-391 is a big victory for the Tories, who have been fighting for years to end
what they call a "wasteful, inefficient" registry.
The bill now goes to a Commons
committee for study - and possible amendment - setting the stage for another
heated national argument over the best way to curb gun violence.
Regardless of what happens next, it
appears the lid has been pried off the gun box.
Conservatives say the registry is a
billion-dollar waste that targets honest gun-owners while doing nothing to fight
crime.
Proponents, including police and
victims-rights groups, say the registry is a useful investigative tool and has
led to more responsible gun ownership, reducing suicides and deadly crimes of
passion.
Leader Michael Ignatieff said earlier
Wednesday that his Liberals, who brought in the long-run registry in response to
the December 1989 massacre of 14 women at a Montreal college, still support "the
principle" of gun control.
But, he added: "the issue is to find
a system of gun control that works for all Canadians - that works in rural
Canada, that works in urban Canada."
Ignatieff floated the notion of
decriminalizing penalties in the gun-registry system, then went on to say he
wants to hear from police, victims' groups and gun owners "to find a way to
rebuild legitimacy for the gun registry in rural Canada. That's not a thing you
can do overnight."
The Conservatives, meanwhile, are
sitting on the 2008 annual report on the gun registry provided by the RCMP to
Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan.
The RCMP strongly supports keeping
the registry alive, and has been working to iron out logistical problems in the
database. The 2008 report should indicate how much success they've had, but Van
Loan won't make it public.
"Canadians don't need another report
to know that the long-gun registry is very efficient at harassing law-abiding
farmers and outdoors enthusiasts, while wasting billions of taxpayer dollars,"
Van Loan's office said in a release Wednesday.
"They don't need another report to
know that the registry does nothing to prevent crime."
Conservatives, backed by a strong
rural voting base, have been dead-set against the long-gun registry for years
but had never forced the issue to a vote in the House of Commons since coming to
power.
Rather, the party has put its
resources behind the private bill by Candice Hoeppner, a young, female,
back-bench Tory MP from Manitoba, knowing that the NDP and Liberal parties
traditionally permit their MPs free votes on such legislation.
The Conservatives have simultaneously
bombarded rural opposition ridings with radio ads pressuring local MPs to vote
in favour of the registry's demise or face a voter backlash. And on Wednesday
the Prime Minister's Office issued talking points to all Conservative MPs on the
bill under the subject line "Message of the Day."
"They clearly are using private
members' bills to achieve the government objective in another way," said Liberal
MP Bob Rae.
But Conservative MP James Rajotte
noted he's run in four elections on a platform of eliminating the gun registry,
"and we've been increasing support for that position each and every time."
The Edmonton MP suggested urban
Albertans may view the registry through the prism of fiscal responsibility "and
they feel that it's not in fact cost-effective in terms of reducing any crime."
The auditor general found in 2006
that the registry had cost almost $1 billion in total through the end of fiscal
2005, but noted the program appeared to have come under better control. Since
handguns and prohibited weapons must still be registered, eliminating the
long-gun portion of the registry would only save taxpayers about $3 million
annually going forward.
Liberal MP James Bagnell, who voted
for the bill, said the debate should serve as a springboard for Canadians to
better understand one another.
"Urban Canadians are passionately in
favour, a lot of them, of a registry . . . . They wonder why anyone in the city
would actually need a gun," the Yukon MP said before the vote.
"In a lot of rural Canada, it's just
a tool that people are used to using every day. They're not afraid of (guns) and
they don't think this is the most effective use of funds to reduce crime."
As if to highlight the urban-rural
divide, Tory MP Daryl Kramp issued the following on his Twitter account:
"feeling sorry for myself - many of my friends are in the hunting camps this
week - my son-in-law just bagged a bear and I am here in Ottawa."
Kramp, who represents a rural riding
in eastern Ontario, also wondered aloud how many empty seats there would be in
the opposition ranks when the vote on Hoeppner's bill was called.
Victoria MP Keith Martin, a Liberal
who once sat as a Canadian Alliance MP, said he'll support the bill now because
he wants it examined further at a Commons committee, where testimony from police
officers and other witnesses could change his views.
"At the end of the day, if the gun
registry is working in the interests of public safety, if it is working in the
interests of saving and helping to save the lives of our police officers, then I
will support it" in a subsequent vote, said Martin.
That is the argument that is being
loudly made by victims' groups, police chiefs and some provincial governments.
Priscilla de Villers, a former
Ontario provincial Tory candidate who became a tough-on-crime policy advocate
after her daughter Nina's 1991 murder, issued a public call for the registry's
survival.
"It is incomprehensible that after
all these years we should still be held hostage by a relatively small group of
citizens, gun owners, who demand the right to possess, exchange or use weapons
without the same restrictions that we, in a civil society, demand from owners of
vehicles and animals," de Villers said in a news release.
The Quebec legislative assembly voted
unanimously Wednesday in support of the registry, and the province's public
safety minister sent a letter - copied to every single Quebec MP - urging his
federal counterpart, Peter Van Loan, to maintain the current system.