Ottawa is under fire from Quebec and Ontario for its modest greenhouse gas
emission reduction targets at the Copenhagen climate talks.
In Denmark on Sunday for the United
Nations climate convention, Quebec Premier Jean Charest condemned the federal
government for the potential economic consequences of its anemic fight against
climate change.
"Commercial sanctions are a real
danger for countries refusing to put in place tough targets," he said. "We could
be vulnerable."
The premier said Quebec's
export-based economy could be an early victim should the European Union act on
its threat to impose a carbon tax on products coming from delinquent countries.
Further, the World Trade Organization
declared last summer it would be acceptable to impose taxes on imports coming
from countries that fail to address climate change or renege on international
engagements.
"We have to be on the lookout because
we're so dependent on foreign markets," said Charest. "We should have stricter
targets in Canada. They're too low."
Charest was backed by Ontario
Environment Minister John Gerretsen, who says he doesn't want his province's
efforts to allow the rest of Canada to get a free ride.
"We are obviously concerned that the
good work we have done may in affect be used by the federal government to allow
others not to have such strong targets as we have," he said.
"We want fairness."
Gerretsen said Ottawa's stance "can
be an embarrassment," and singled out the ongoing tar sands development in
Alberta and Saskatchewan as a specific problem.
"If they are developed there may have
to be larger greenhouse gas emission (cuts) elsewhere in the country in order to
meet our overall targets," he said.
Both provinces have adopted
aggressive reduction targets and are looking to implement cap-and-trade
programs.
Quebec, following the EU's example,
announced plans to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 2020 to 20 per cent
below 1990 levels.
The Conservative government has a
modest reduction goal of three per cent below 1990 levels. So far, it has no
clear plan on how it is going to achieve that target.
And it's unlikely that Canada will
meet its obligations under the Kyoto accord, which set its emission reduction
target at six per cent below 1990 levels by 2012.
By 2007, Canada's emissions had
jumped 26 per cent over 1990 levels, mainly due to tar sands development.
Climate experts suggest countries
commit to a drop of 25 to 40 per cent in emissions to avoid a potential two
degree rise in global temperatures by 2020.